Most founders who come to me want a patent. Very few are thinking about which country that patent covers. Patent rights are jurisdictional, so the real question is where else your invention will earn money or meet competitors. Once that answer reaches past the US, foreign patent filing becomes part of the plan. You have two main paths: a PCT application, or a direct filing in each country you pick. The right one depends on how many countries you need and how sure you are about them.
It usually comes up when we talk about what rights a patent gives you. Then the practical questions follow. Are you going to make this product here in the US or somewhere else? Where are you likely to sell it?
Many founders arrive with big eyes. They want to conquer the world, and I think that is probably the correct attitude when you are starting something new. For most of my clients, the US is still the most important jurisdiction. But we live in a much more global economy now, and it is very easy to order things across borders. A patent is an economic asset. When you see that your invention will be lucrative outside the US, that is the time to start this conversation, and it can happen rather quickly.
A PCT application works a lot like a provisional application. It lets you delay the decision about which countries to enter, because one filing keeps your options open across the treaty member countries without naming specific ones yet. That helps when you are starting out and don't yet know where you will have the most success.
Jeff Holman, our founder, describes it as a way to open the door without having to walk through it yet.
The costs still come later. Each country you eventually enter has its own costs, and for a new company those can add up. So before you enter a country, ask two questions. Are you making money there? Is somebody competing with you there?
Count the countries. If you are fairly sure you only want one or two foreign jurisdictions, the cost of the PCT might not be worth it for you. In that case I talk with clients about direct filing, which means filing an application straight in that country and skipping the PCT.
This often comes up with US companies that sell mainly in the US and Canada. If Canada is the only other market, the PCT pricing often doesn't make sense, so we discuss a direct filing in Canada. It also comes up when a company manufactures in one place, such as China or Vietnam. Eastern Europe is a popular choice too.
There is a trade-off. When you skip the PCT, you give up the ability to later go into those other countries.
Most clients meet this decision at one of two moments. If you are filing a US non-provisional application now, you have a full year from that first filing date to decide whether to file a PCT application.
If you already filed a provisional application, the 12-month date is when you have to decide on both the US non-provisional and the PCT. That stacks two filings at once, and PCT costs run a little higher than a US filing alone.
Many startups are not ready at that point. They are still finding out what their market is and how lucrative it is, or they are pre-revenue. Unfortunately, at that 12-month date, you do have to make a decision. You should start thinking about foreign filing about six months before your 12-month date.
Start with where you sell and where you make. Patents let you restrict others from making your invention as well as selling it. So also think about where a competitor would make or sell a similar product. If a country has a large manufacturing base, consider it even if you don't plan to make anything there yourself.
Is the US still the most important place to file? For most of my clients it is. Foreign filing asks where else the invention will earn money or face competitors.
Does foreign filing replace my US application? Jeff Holman calls it a parallel path. Your US application is one path, and foreign filing runs next to it with costs of its own.
Planning to sell or manufacture outside the US? Book a free 30-minute strategy call, and we can talk through which filing path fits your next steps: Book a strategy call
Get one practical legal insight for growing businesses every Wednesday. Subscribe to FraxLaw: Subscribe to FraxLaw
This article is law firm marketing and shares general information, not legal advice. It does not create an attorney-client relationship. Your situation may differ, so talk with an attorney about your specific facts.